Third Best and Fairest (J.J. Joyce Trophy) – Collingwood Forever https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au The complete history of Australia's greatest sporting club Tue, 30 Jan 2024 23:13:09 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.0.21 Jack Crisp https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/jack-crisp/ Sun, 11 Sep 2016 06:21:50 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/?post_type=cf_player&p=10695 Steele Sidebottom https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/steele-sidebottom/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:03:00 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/steele-sidebottom/ Dale Thomas https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/dale-thomas/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:49 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/dale-thomas/ He represented Vic Country at the U18 National Championships where he was named as an All-Australian as a half forward, and he was also named in the TAC Cup Team of the Year on the wing, polling 11 votes in the Morrish Medal. Thomas was drafted to Collingwood with the second selection in the 2005 National Draft, behind Carlton’s Marc Murphy. It was considered a surprise at the time, as Gippsland teammate Xavier Ellis was the hot tip to be selected by the Magpies with their first selection. Thomas first appeared for his new club in the NAB Cup of 2006 and was blooded officially against Adelaide in round one at Docklands. He took centre stage immediately, kicking two early goals and pulling in an early contender for Mark of the Year. He was nominated for the AFL Rising Star the following week. He again attracted media attention when he starred on ANZAC Day in front of 91,234 fans, taking one of the marks of the season and kicking two important goals. He was important in the win over the Eagles in round 16 when the Pies snapped a three game losing streak, but he broke his collarbone leaping as the third man up at a ruck contest in the loss to the Crows in round 18. He managed to return in time for the  Elimination Final against the Western Bulldogs. Incredibly, for a first year player, he spent only one game with Williamstown, the club’s VFL affiliate, during his comeback from injury, and showed his liking for the big stage with four goals in a final against the Northern Bullants. At season’s end he was awarded the Harry Collier Medal as Best First Year Player. There was no sign of second year blues for Thomas, who was a strong contributor all throughout 2007 at half forward and occasionally in the midfield. He enjoyed a purple patch mid-season, kicking four against the Swans in Sydney to win three Brownlow votes, and single-handedly winning the game for the Pies against St Kilda in round 14. The win over the Saints was memorable for the ‘goal that wasn’t’ – when Thomas evaded two tacklers before dribbling a miraculous goal from the boundary line, only for the goal to be disallowed as it was deemed he’d stepped out of bounds. He tapered a little as the season ended, but put in a gutsy performance against West Coast in the Semi-Final and finished sixth in the Copeland Trophy. Thomas had a steady 2008 season, playing mostly in attack where he nailed 23 goals in 22 games. He was sublime in the 100 point win against the Eagles, attracting plenty of coverage for his four-bounce goal and subsequent celebration. He added an important goal against Adelaide late in the third term in the Elimination Final and represented Australia in the International Rules series under coach Mick Malthouse, ending the year in eighth place in the Copeland Trophy. Season 2009 saw Thomas employed in a different role as to previous seasons, spending a lot of the year as a defensive half forward. He still had his moments, kicking the match winner against the Western Bulldogs in round 15 and bagging three majors and 16 disposals against Brisbane in round 18. He signed a new two year contract mid-season, and was one of the better performers in the Qualifying Final loss to St Kilda, kicking two goals. But it was in 2010 that Thomas transformed his game, going from a flashy half forward to a full time wingman. He increased his fitness base and subsequently his output, upping his average disposal count to 23.9 (up from 17.2) and his tackle count to 3.5 (up from 2.9). Importantly, he became a real weapon as the fourth midfielder behind Dane Swan, Scott Pendlebury and Luke Ball, and still managed to push forward to score goals (18.14 for the season). He was excellent throughout the finals campaign, kicking a goal in each final and starting with 32 disposals against the Bulldogs in the Qualifying Final. Thomas etched his name into club folklore with his performances across the two Grand Finals against St Kilda, enhancing his reputation enormously in the process. He had 26 touches and eight tackles in the drawn Grand Final, and was one player to stand up when the heat was on in the final quarter. He repeated the dose with 27 possessions in the Replay, this time ending the day a premiership player. He ran third in the Copeland Trophy and tied for the Bob Rose Award (Best Player in Finals). In 2011, he continued his improvement as a midfielder to the point where St Kilda coach Ross Lyon mused mid-season that Thomas may be the best player in the competition. Lyon’s comments followed a hot streak in which Thomas polled maximum Brownlow votes for two weeks running against the Crows and the Eagles. He was suspended for two weeks mid-season for striking Saint Clint Jones but it did little to take the wind out of his sails. Another suspension in round 23 against Fremantle did, however, meaning he missed the Qualifying Final. Thomas went down fighting in the Grand Final defeat (31 disposals and seven tackles), and played in the pre-season premiership, finishing the year ranked sixth in the Copeland Trophy. After the boom years of 2010-2011, Thomas’ output wavered in his last two years in Black and White. He played 20 of a possible 25 games in 2012, showcasing his newly shorn head in the process. He kicked 22 goals for the year but lacked the impact of the previous campaigns, save for his match-winning burst of three goals in the emotional Semi-Final win over West Coast. The following years was the toughest of Thomas’ eight seasons in Collingwood colours. Foot and ankle injuries held him to only five senior games, his lowest tally since his debut year of 2006 (when he played 16 games). He missed the entire NAB Cup owing to foot surgery and was brought back via the VFL where he was one of the best afield in the final practice match against the AIS-AFL Academy at the MCG when he won 25 possessions and laid five tackles. He followed that up with 22 disposals against North Ballarat in the first round of the VFL and was quickly brought back into the senior side for the round three encounter with Hawthorn. Thomas had 19 disposals from 86 per cent game time but sustained a kick to the back of his ankle that would eventually see him sidelined for the majority of the season. In the month that followed, he was used as the substitute against Richmond and was productive as a rebounding half back against St Kilda (34 possessions and a Brownlow vote) and Fremantle (25 possessions). Unfortunately, the condition of Thomas’ ankle forced him to take a 14-week absence from the game. His attitude and commitment during his rehabilitation allowed him an attempt at an eleventh hour comeback ahead of the finals, but his season came to a halt during the second quarter of the VFL team’s win over Sandringham when he jogged from the field after experiencing discomfort in his ankle With that, his season was done, and the attention shifted to his whereabouts for the 2014 season. Thomas eventually made the decision to cross to Carlton as a free agent where he was reunited with Malthouse, who coached him in the first 132 games of his career. By way of compensation, Collingwood received pick No. 11 in the National Draft, which the club later upgraded to pick No. 6 in a trade with West Coast. The Magpies used selection No. 6 on young South Australian prodigy Matthew Scharenberg. While Thomas’ move to Princes Park evoked strong emotion from the Collingwood faithful, it will never forget his role in the acquisition of the club’s 15th VFL/AFL premiership in 2010.]]> Scott Pendlebury https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/scott-pendlebury/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:49 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/scott-pendlebury/ Heath Shaw https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/heath-shaw/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:48 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/heath-shaw/ Although he was mooted as a potential debutant early in 2004, Shaw made his AFL debut late in 2005 and had an impressive start as he demonstrated his ball-winning skills in defence. To start 2006 he was a late call up against Hawthorn in round 2 after having won 35 touches for Williamstown the previous day. After that, he played in all the remaining games and rapidly became a major component of the team as a running, penetrating half-back who could launch constant attacks, as illustrated when he won the ANZAC Day Medal in 2007. His influence was so strong that by the end of the season, opposing teams were allocating negating forwards to the job of limiting him. Always busy on the field, he had been diagnosed with ADD as a kid, and his energetic style endeared him to the hearts of the Collingwood faithful. He was touted as a future leader after he ran fourth in the 2007 best and fairest and continued the momentum into early 2008 but his form wasn’t quite as consistent. His season ended dramatically when the club suspended him after round 18 when he and teammate Alan Didak found themselves in off-field strife. He admitted later that it shook his feeling of being invulnerable. He responded in the best way possible by running third in the 2009 best and fairest and at the start of 2010 he joined the leadership group. A fine year ended with a premiership for the Magpies and he provided a highlight of the Grand Final Replay when he desperately lunged to smother a Nick Riewoldt kick from the square. In late 2011 he was suspended for eight games (with a further six suspended) in a football betting scandal, but he bounced back to continue as one of the foremost running half backs in the competition. Unfortunately, a number of undisciplined acts in 2013 left him on the outer and he was placed on the trade market, being traded to Greater Western Sydney in exchange for Taylor Adams.]]> Travis Cloke https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/travis-cloke/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:45 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/travis-cloke/ And what a package that was. Across his 12 seasons in the black and white, his tally of goals and capacity to drag down important contested marks stamped him as one of the most important and influential players of his era. Ignore the wayward kicking for a moment and look at the statistics: he kicked more goals than all but six players in Magpie history – Gordon Coventry, Peter McKenna, Dick Lee, Peter Daicos, Saverio Rocca and Alby Pannam. But even more importantly, it’s worth remembering that Travis Cloke was not your classic stay-at-home full-forward. He often played as more a centre half-forward or even high half-forward: he had a huge engine and would often present as a leading target for marks on the wing, or even deeper, then wheel on to that famous left-foot for a booming kick into the forward line. So goals alone are not how his legacy should be measured. So it’s the contested marking for which he will be most remembered. Immensely strong with a good leap and remarkably ‘sticky’ hands, Cloke at his best was almost unstoppable. Across three seasons – 2010 to 2012 – he recorded three of the top 12 highest contested mark counts in a season ever recorded. He could wrestle an opponent out of contention in one-on-one contests, or fly into a pack against three defenders and almost always emerge with ball in hand. Despite his strength he was very much a gentle giant (though you wouldn’t want to have been on the end of one of his bone-crunching tackles), but even then he was rarely looked after by the umpires. Indeed, at times they seemed to penalise him for being so much stronger, and so much better, than most of his opponents. But Cloke rarely complained or remonstrated: he just shrugged and prepared for the next contest. Football had always been in Travis’s DNA, with his father, David, having a celebrated career with Richmond and Collingwood. David’s three sons – Jason, Cameron and Travis – were born within a five-year window, but there was always a belief the youngest might be the best. Each son had the luxury of choosing between Richmond and Collingwood, but most believed the trio was a package deal. Jason, taken by the Magpies in 2000, said as much after he was joined by Cameron in 2002: “There’s still another one to come. Hopefully we can all play at the same club.” Richmond launched a late bid to convince Travis that he would be better off at another club. But Collingwood was never going to let this young talent from the Eastern Ranges slip through the net. He debuted for Collingwood on Anzac Day in 2005, kicking a goal and having 15 touches. All three brothers played in the same match the following week against St Kilda, a one-off moment that Travis would later declare to be one of his most cherished in football. It also provided one memorable passage of play when Jason (No.34) took control of the ball, gave it off to Cameron (No.33) further down the ground, and he send it down to Travis (No.32) deep in attack. At the end of 2006, the Magpies made the difficult decision to move both Jason (76 games) and Cameron (21 games) on. As disappointed as Travis was, it did not affect his football. Indeed he had an outstanding 2007 season, culminating in a Copeland Trophy win – one of only six who won it at 20 or younger. From that season on, Cloke’s was one of the first names on the Collingwood team sheet each week. A contract standoff between his management and the club caused tensions in 2012, which impacted on the forward’s form. Soon after the 2012 preliminary final loss to Sydney, Cloke signed a lucrative five-year deal to stay at Collingwood, saying that he wanted to remain loyal to the club. He followed it up with a strong season in 2013, finishing third again in the Copeland, winning a second All-Australian berth, and kicked 68.51, narrowly missing out on a Coleman Medal for the second time in three seasons. Like his father, he had countless kicking coaches – from Saverio Rocca to Ben Dixon – and dealt with psychologists and body movement experts, seeking conventional and not-so-conventional solutions. For a time, he even took to using an iPod and headphones in his training sessions to replicate the noise of the crowd. But as the game changed in shape, and the influence of power forwards began to diminish, Cloke’s impact on games began to drop off through 2014 (39 goals) and 2015 (34 goals). He had one last glorious hurrah in 2016, four goals against Greater Western Sydney, but at the end of the year sought a move to the Western Bulldogs. He had limited on-field impact at the Dogs, but was widely lauded for publicly talking about his decision to take time out that year to deal with depression. In the end, Travis Cloke will go down as one of the best Collingwood key forwards of the post-war era. If he’d been just a little more accurate in front of goal, his standing would be even higher. But if he’d been more clinical in front of goal, then some other part of the package might have been diminished. So rather than focus on the flaws we can instead celebrate the whole: the extraordinary contribution and wonderful career of one of footy’s true nice guys.  ]]> Dane Swan https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/dane-swan/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:40 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/dane-swan/ In the years that followed, Swan made incredible improvement to the point where he became the 2011 Brownlow Medalist, and earned the label of ‘untaggable’ from many commentators. A strongly built midfielder who is dangerous if released to half forward, Swan’s unique ability to repeatedly out-sprint his opponents, allowing him to power from contest to contest, made him Collingwood’s most consistent player of the Malthouse-Buckley era. Criticised earn on by some for his occasionally errant kicking, Swan’s disposal was soon considered to be as good as any other. His barrel chest meant he could hunt down the ball at the stoppages and explode away from them courtesy of his deceptive pace. Far from a front runner, Swan averaged 84.4 tackles between 2007 and 2011. He also had ability to make himself a threat in attack, be it around stoppages, outrunning his opponent when the side’s in possession and when isolated one-out where his underrated ability overhead made him the complete package. After a disappointing and injury-plagued 2014, he returned to stellar form in 2015, running second in the Copeland Trophy. He began the 2016 campaign well, starring during the NAB Challenge, only for a rare foot injury suffered minutes into the season opener against Sydney to end both his season and his career.]]> James Clement https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/james-clement/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:34 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/james-clement/ Malthouse, it turns out, had unsuccessfully tried to recruit Clement as a teenager to West Coast. The coach had watched him as a junior in the mid-1990s, but the Dockers had first dibs as part of their zone selection options, given that he had played with South Fremantle in the WAFL. He made his name at South as a mobile half-back and winger, but once he joined Freo he spent most of his time in defence, quickly becoming a regular in the seniors. In 1998 he had a brief burst of success as a forward, kicking five goals in consecutive matches against West Coast and Essendon, but mostly he was a defender. He played all 22 games for the Dockers in 1999 but managed just eight the following year. Malthouse was by now at Collingwood, so when Judkins suggested Clement was frustrated and might be gettable, the coach couldn’t have been keener. He’d actually kept in touch with Clement over the years, and the two were keen to work together.     At the end of 2000 he was traded to Collingwood in a complex deal that saw him joined in black-and-white by Fremantle small forward Brodie Holland, while Paul Williams headed to Sydney. And as good as Willo was for the Swans, nobody doubted that the Pies ended up with the best of that deal. Clement was an instant hit at Collingwood, snagging three goals in his first game (only 10 more would come in his Magpie career). He was understated off the field and could not stand hype. On the field, he loved the contest, hated fuss, and preferred a low-key approach. He was tall, strong, good overhead but also quick and agile, capable of playing on both tall and small forwards. An educated man, he was one of those players who was never going to have to rely on his football career to steer him through life, and yet he played the game as though his life depended on it. He rapidly developed into one of the game’s premier defenders, missing only six games in his first six seasons at the club. His durability amazed some teammates. In a contest against his former side in 2004, he played three quarters with a suspected fracture cheekbone. And in a practice game earlier that year he suffered an eye injury that would not stop bleeding for two days, prompting concern over the health of his eyesight. Clement’s consistency and his rare ability to win his contests, regardless of the result, saw him become a star in a revamped team that would contest the 2002 and 2003 Grand Finals. He was third in the Copeland Trophy in his second season at the club, and also shared the best finals player award that year. He then won consecutive best-and-fairest awards in 2004 and 2005, and finished second in 2006. He was named in two All-Australian teams (2004-05), though some of his teammates insist he should have been selected in more. “He was probably the best defender in the competition for two or three years,” Scott Burns maintained. “He was an All-Australian lock. I still can’t believe he didn’t make it (the team) in a few other years.” Clement took on and eclipsed some of the best forwards of his time, and is widely remembered for one clash in 2006 where he outpointed Essendon’s James Hird so comprehensively – often with perfectly timed subtle nudges under the ball – that the AFL subsequently introduced the “hands in the back” rule. “He absolutely dominated James Hird that day,” recalled Burns, “and Hird sooked and Essendon sooked, and we got the stupid ‘hands in the back rule’ as a result.” Clement could play on power-marking big men or the fleet of foot, mobile smaller attacking players, which set him apart from other more predictable, one-dimensional defenders. “Jimmy could play on the smallest of forwards and the tallest of forwards, and he would knock them all over,” Nathan Buckley said. “He was hard, really hard, and he made himself that on and off the field.”   He was rarely beaten one-on-one, was an exceptional rebounding defender and in an age where metres gained was not necessarily a focus, his ability to break free from his opponent and roost the ball 60m out of the defensive zone was a huge part of the Magpies’ game plan. He was a beautiful kick of the football and rarely missed his targets. But more than anything it was class and composure that James Clement brought to the heart of Collingwood’s defence. He was cool, unruffled and seemingly always in control. The whole defence seemed tighter and more assured from the moment he stepped into it. As understated as he was off the field, Clement proved extraordinary guidance and inspiration on it, and stepped into the captaincy breech whenever Buckley was missing. It wasn’t until 2007 that injuries began to catch up with him. He managed only 13 of 25 games that year, missing 11 straight with a calf injury. He returned in Round 18, and did not miss a beat as the Magpies won their way through to another finals series. Fittingly for a player who won the club’s best finals player in 2002 and 2006, Clement was among Collingwood’s best players in the heartbreaking preliminary final loss to Geelong in 2007. Few took much notice when he gave a wave to the crowd as he left the MCG that night. He was 31, and seemed to have so much more left to give, almost certainly as the next captain. But Clement was ready to move to the next phase of his life, helping to support his wife, Jeanne, who was undergoing a health battle. He quietly gave the game away, with no fanfare, no media conference and no looking back. For a guy who eschewed the limelight for so much of his career, it seemed the perfect way to go out. James Clement finished his career as one of the AFL’s most respected defenders of the early 2000s, and his legacy was upheld by several of his younger teammates such as Nick Maxwell and Heritier Lumumba, who regularly cited Clement’s influence as a key driver behind the nucleus of the group that was to take out the 2010 premiership.  ]]> Shane Wakelin https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/shane-wakelin/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:33 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/shane-wakelin/ In later years, he admitted that he had lied to coach Mick Malthouse when asked about the extent of his Achilles problem when the coach had interviewed him about coming to Collingwood. He was one of a band of experienced players who added substance to the Collingwood side and in 2002 enjoyed one of his best seasons, finishing fifth in the Copeland Trophy. He played in the Magpies’ Grand Final sides of 2002-03, locking horns in several engrossing duels with Brisbane’s Alistair Lynch and getting the better of him on several occasions. Wakelin was a stalwart in defence in 2004 until he broke his arm and missed the final six games of the season, and his third placing in the best and fairest of 2005 was his highest individual honour. His career began to flag as a young group of Magpie backmen, led by Nick Maxwell and Heritier Lumumba, became senior players in the years that followed, but instead of fading into the darkness, Wakelin enjoyed an Indian summer. After playing just four games in the first 10 rounds of 2007, the then 32-year-old Wakelin returned for the Queen’s Birthday clash with Melbourne and missed just two more games as his side shocked the competition by charging into the Preliminary Final. During the finals series, Wakelin performed admirably on the likes of Barry Hall and Cameron Mooney and typified his team’s fighting spirit with a one-handed tackle on Mooney at a critical stage of the epic Preliminary Final. In 2008, Wakelin’s renacconce continued, managing 20 games in his final season at the age of 34. He was caught in the crossfire when Barry Hall took a swipe at hime durng the team’s visit to Stadium Australia in round 14 and he notched his 250th career game in round 20, fittingly, against Port Adelaide, the club at which he played much of his junior football. Although he missed the Elimination Final, he returned for one last hurrah against his old club St Kilda in the Semi-Final. To the end he was an honorable and respected footballer who fashioned a proud record, and later returned to St Kilda where he worked in the club’s administration.]]> Tarkyn Lockyer https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/tarkyn-lockyer/ Wed, 16 Jul 2014 12:02:26 +0000 http://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/players/tarkyn-lockyer/ He had an outstanding 2000 season and went from being a bit player to be one of Collingwood’s most valuable contributors with dash and poise from defence. After finishing as runner-up to skipper Nathan Buckley for the Magpies’ 2000 best and fairest award, a horrible clash with teammate Jarrod Molloy in round 20 put an end to Lockyer’s 2001 season as he spent the last two weeks out with concussion. In addition to taking on any role in defence, he could also lend a hand in attack. He finished fifth in the 2001 best and fairest voting and a place higher the following year to confirm his importance in the Magpie set-up. After playing in Collingwood’s losing 2002 Grand Final side, Lockyer ruptured the anterior cruciate in his right knee in round three and had to undergo knee reconstruction surgery. Then he injured a foot in his comeback in February and did not return until round nine of 2004. It took him a while to settle back in, but by the end of the season his courage and accurate use of the ball were once again prominent. He ran equal second in the best and fairest after a sensational year in 2007 and also finished in the top 10 in 2008 and 2009, by which time he was being used primarily as a small forward. In a reverse of his bad injury saga he did not miss a game from mid-2004 til early 2010, racking up 136 in a row before losing his place as young players were pushed through. He retired at the end of the season and was immediately given a position on the coaching panel. Lockyer led Collingwood’s VFL team in 2011 and 2012 before becoming Midfield Development Coach in 2013.]]>